Accommodations and places to stay in Fire Island

Search among 22 available lodgings in Fire Island from 50+ providers

Destination
Where do you want to go?
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
We’ll open Booking.com in a new tab for fair comparison.
0Filter & Sort
View map
21-22 out of 22
15 SenecaHoliday home
9.3
Perfect3 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
10 adults
3 bedrooms
5 beds
Guests can enjoy hiking and fishing at the 4-star 15 Seneca, around 20 minutes' walk from Island Mermaid.
FromNZ$ 2 584 /nightSelect
10 CayugaHoliday home
10 adults
4 bedrooms
4 beds
Hiking, cycling, and fishing are offered at the 3-star 10 Cayuga Ocean Bay Park, which is a mere 10 minutes' walk from Island Mermaid.
FromNZ$ 1 011 /nightSelect
  • 1
  • 2