Accommodations and places to stay in Fire Island

Search among 22 available lodgings in Fire Island from 50+ providers

Destination
Where do you want to go?
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
We’ll open Booking.com in a new tab for fair comparison.
0Filter & Sort
View map
1-20 out of 22
Grove HotelHotel
8.8
Great145 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Barrett Beach Park is at a distance of 4.7 km from the Grove Cherry Grove and The Sunken Forest is approximately 10 minutes' drive away.
FromNZ$ 593 /nightSelect
Clegg'S HotelHotel
8.5
Great46 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
The Clegg'S is situated at a distance of 2.2 km from Dunewood and approximately a 10-minute ride from The Sunken Forest.
FromNZ$ 481 /nightSelect
The Madison Fire Island PinesGuest house
9.2
Perfect14 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Featuring 9 rooms with views of the garden, the Madison Fire Island Pines is set just 1.2 km from Fire Island National Seashore.
FromNZ$ 563 /nightSelect
The Pines Men-Only StayHomestay
9.5
Perfect51 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
FromNZ$ 278 /nightSelect
LovefinsLuxury tent
5.0
Needs improvement2 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
FromNZ$ 342 /nightSelect
Huron HideawayHoliday home
9.5
Perfect4 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
6 adults
3 bedrooms
3 beds
While staying at the 4-star Huron Hideaway you are invited to discover Dunewood, set 3.8 km away, or Fair Harbor, which is about 10 minutes' drive away.
FromNZ$ 1 938 /nightSelect
The Surfcomber Unit 3Motel
Select
The Surfcomber Multi-Residence HomeApartment
Select
Coastal Cove CottageHotel
The Sunken Forest is at a distance of 2.4 km from the Coastal Cove, while Sailors Haven Visitor Center is approximately 10 minutes' drive away.
Select
Cherry Grove EnchantmentHoliday home
Select
Fire Island GemApartment
9.0
Perfect2 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
FromNZ$ 1 104 /nightSelect
Seaclusion GardensHoliday home
FromNZ$ 1 753 /nightSelect
ParadisoHoliday home
10.0
Perfect1 total review
our site & Booking.com
FromNZ$ 3 246 /nightSelect
Poolside Chic By The SeaHoliday home
5.0
Needs improvement1 total review
our site & Booking.com
FromNZ$ 2 919 /nightSelect
Cayuga Street Sunshine RetreatHoliday home
9.5
Perfect2 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
FromNZ$ 2 880 /nightSelect
Seaside Escape On HuronHoliday home
FromNZ$ 1 814 /nightSelect
The Surfcomber Unit 1Apartment
9.5
Perfect2 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
The largest option:
10 adults
2 bedrooms
4 beds
While staying at The Surfcomber Ocean Bay Park you are invited to discover Fire Island Lighthouse, set around 7 km away, or The Sunken Forest, which is nearly 25 minutes' walk away.
FromNZ$ 316 /nightSelect
Robbins Rest RetreatHoliday home
10.0
Perfect1 total review
our site & Booking.com
12 adults
6 bedrooms
6 beds
Set about 5 km from Lighthouse Beach, the rooms in the 3-star Robbins Rest Retreat Villa have views of sea.
FromNZ$ 2 554 /nightSelect
37 Ocean Bay BlvdHoliday home
5.0
Needs improvement1 total review
our site & Booking.com
7 adults
4 bedrooms
4 beds
The Sunken Forest is around 3 km from the 3-star 37 Ocean Bay Blvd Ocean Bay Park, while Island Mermaid is approximately 15 minutes' walk away.
FromNZ$ 1 755 /nightSelect
195 Wilmot RoadHoliday home
6 adults
3 bedrooms
3 beds
Dunewood is approximately a 25-minute walk from the 3-star 195 Wilmot Road, and is ideal for an energetic jog or hiking, cycling, and fishing.
FromNZ$ 628 /nightSelect
Show more
  • 1
  • 2

Lodging in Fire Island essential information

🏨 Lodging in Fire Island 22
👛 Lowest price 1477 NZD