Fishers Island NY Hotels

Search among 42 available hotels and places to stay in Fishers Island from 50+ providers

Check-in
Wed, 25 Dec
-
Check-out
Thu, 26 Dec
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Check-in
Wed, 25 Dec
-
Check-out
Thu, 26 Dec
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
Check-in
Wed, 25 Dec
-
Check-out
Thu, 26 Dec
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
View map
Hotels
Holiday rentals
All types
1-42 out of 42
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
Places to stay near Fishers Island
Taber Inn Mystic Exterior photo
Taber Inn Mystic
Inn
8.4
Great230 reviews
Map
8.8 km from Fishers Island8.8 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 263 /nightSelect
Hilton Mystic Hotel Exterior photo
Hilton Mystic Hotel
Hotel
8.4
Great164 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 210 /nightSelect
Spark By Hilton Mystic Groton Hotel Exterior photo
Spark By Hilton Mystic Groton
Hotel
8.4
Great590 reviews
Map
12.1 km from Fishers Island12.1 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 113 /nightSelect
Holiday Inn Express Mystic, An Ihg Hotel Exterior photo
Holiday Inn Express Mystic, An Ihg Hotel
Resort
8.2
Great81 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 192 /nightSelect
Rodeway Inn Groton Exterior photo
Rodeway Inn
Inn
7.8
Very good44 reviews
Map
11.9 km from Fishers Island11.9 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 125 /nightSelect
Americas Best Value Inn Stonington Mystic Exterior photo
Americas Best Value Inn Stonington Mystic
Hotel
7.8
Very good50 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 109 /nightSelect
House Of 1833 Bed And Breakfast Mystic Exterior photo
House Of 1833 Bed And Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast
7.8
Very good16 reviews
Map
14.0 km from Fishers Island14.0 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 652 /nightSelect
Best Western Mystic Hotel Exterior photo
Best Western Mystic Hotel
Hotel
8.4
Great105 reviews
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
Select
Hyatt Place Mystic Hotel Exterior photo
Hyatt Place Mystic
Hotel
8.4
Great137 reviews
Map
11.2 km from Fishers Island11.2 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 201 /nightSelect
Hilton Garden Inn Mystic/Groton Exterior photo
Hilton Garden Inn Mystic/Groton
Hotel
8.4
Great45 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 204 /nightSelect
Mystic Marriott Hotel And Spa Groton Exterior photo
Mystic Marriott Hotel And Spa
Hotel
8.4
Great46 reviews
Map
10.8 km from Fishers Island10.8 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 266 /nightSelect
Quality Inn Mystic-Groton Exterior photo
Quality Inn Mystic-Groton
Hotel
8.2
Great134 reviews
Map
12.1 km from Fishers Island12.1 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 139 /nightSelect
Residence Inn Mystic Groton Exterior photo
Residence Inn Mystic Groton
Hotel
8.4
Great46 reviews
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 368 /nightSelect
Hampton Inn Groton/Mystic Exterior photo
Hampton Inn Groton/Mystic
Hotel
8.2
Great99 reviews
Map
11.3 km from Fishers Island11.3 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 194 /nightSelect
Inn At Mystic Exterior photo
Inn At Mystic
Inn
8.4
Great127 reviews
Map
9.0 km from Fishers Island9.0 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 139 /nightSelect
Groton Inn & Suites Exterior photo
Groton Inn & Suites
Inn
8.4
Great49 reviews
Map
12.2 km from Fishers Island12.2 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 139 /nightSelect
Holiday Inn New London, An Ihg Hotel Exterior photo
Holiday Inn New London, An Ihg Hotel
Hotel
8.4
Great173 reviews
Map
13.0 km from Fishers Island13.0 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 298 /nightSelect
Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic Exterior photo
Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic
Hotel
8.2
Great146 reviews
Map
11.9 km from Fishers Island11.9 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 194 /nightSelect
Pleasant View Inn Westerly Exterior photo
Pleasant View Inn
Hotel
8.2
Great61 reviews
Map
15.2 km from Fishers Island15.2 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 352 /nightSelect
Whitehall Mansion Bed & Breakfast Mystic Exterior photo
Whitehall Mansion
Bed & Breakfast
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 270 /nightSelect
The Whaler'S Inn Mystic Exterior photo
The Whaler'S Inn
Hotel
8.4
Great67 reviews
Map
9.3 km from Fishers Island9.3 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 966 /nightSelect
Howard Johnson By Wyndham Mystic Hotel Exterior photo
Howard Johnson By Wyndham Mystic
Hotel
8.4
Great243 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 141 /nightSelect
Rodeway Inn Mystic Exterior photo
Rodeway Inn Mystic
Motel
8.0
Great186 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 106 /nightSelect
Ramada By Wyndham Groton Mystic Hotel Exterior photo
Ramada By Wyndham Groton Mystic
Hotel
8.0
Great125 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 90 /nightSelect
Super 8 By Wyndham Groton Hotel Exterior photo
Super 8 By Wyndham Groton
Hotel
8.0
Great114 reviews
Map
12.5 km from Fishers Island12.5 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 83 /nightSelect
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Groton Exterior photo
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Groton
Hotel
7.8
Very good96 reviews
Map
12.2 km from Fishers Island12.2 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 90 /nightSelect
Days Inn & Suites By Wyndham Groton Near The Casinos Exterior photo
Days Inn & Suites By Wyndham Groton Near The Casinos
Hotel
7.6
Very good64 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 106 /nightSelect
Baymont By Wyndham Groton/Mystic Hotel Exterior photo
Baymont By Wyndham Groton/Mystic
Hotel
8.2
Great100 reviews
Map
13.0 km from Fishers Island13.0 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 194 /nightSelect
Flagship Inn & Suites Groton Exterior photo
Flagship Inn & Suites
Hotel
8.0
Great147 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 79 /nightSelect
Motel 6-Groton, Ct - Casinos Nearby Exterior photo
Motel 6-Groton, Ct - Casinos Nearby
Hotel
8.2
Great76 reviews
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 127 /nightSelect
Windsor Motel Groton Exterior photo
Windsor Motel
Motel
8.2
Great37 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 97 /nightSelect
Hilltop Express Inn Groton Exterior photo
Hilltop Express Inn
Hotel
7.8
Very good105 reviews
Map
9.7 km from Fishers Island9.7 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 174 /nightSelect
Mystic River Hotel & Suites Exterior photo
Mystic River Hotel & Suites
Hotel
8.2
Great132 reviews
Map
11.8 km from Fishers Island11.8 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 180 /nightSelect
Breezeway Resort Westerly Room photo
Breezeway Resort
Hotel
8.4
Great40 reviews
Map
16.0 km from Fishers Island16.0 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 1 445 /nightSelect
Thames Street Inn New London Exterior photo
Thames Street Inn
Hotel
7.4
Very good2 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
Select
Sandy Shore Motel Westerly Exterior photo
Sandy Shore Motel
Motel
8.4
Great1 review
Map
15.9 km from Fishers Island15.9 km from City Centre
Select
The Hotel Maria Westerly Exterior photo
The Hotel Maria
Hotel
8.6
Great47 reviews
Map
15.8 km from Fishers Island15.8 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 2 758 /nightSelect
Harbor View Landing Hotel Mystic Exterior photo
Harbor View Landing
Hotel
8.2
Great25 reviews
Map
8.3 km from Fishers Island8.3 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 527 /nightSelect
Sandcastle Beachfront Inn Westerly Exterior photo
Sandcastle Beachfront Inn
Inn
Map
15.8 km from Fishers Island15.8 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 432 /nightSelect
Super 8 Groton Hotel Exterior photo
Super 8 Groton
Hotel
Map
12.6 km from Fishers Island12.6 km from City Centre
FromNZ$ 243 /nightSelect
Borough Beach Apartment Stonington Exterior photo
Borough Beach Apartment
Guest house
Map
9.4 km from Fishers Island9.4 km from City Centre
Select
Thames Inn And Marina Groton Exterior photo
Thames Inn And Marina
Motel
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
Select

Fishers Island hotels essential information

🏨 Hotels in Fishers Island 42
👛 Lowest price 79 NZD
✍️ Hotels Reviews 3 950